| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by John D at 10:52, 30th November 2025 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
That rolling stock strategy is due out next summer, according to Lord Hendy. It sounds as though she actually knows about it, which is encouraging in a transport minister.
While having a national rolling stock strategy is one benefit of re-nationalisation, it's difficult to see how this can be produced without also having a strategy for electrification, and ensuring it is implemented.
Labour have talked about Nationalisation for years, and by next summer will have been in power 2 years.
It's good there will be a longer term strategy, but theses 2 years should not have been paralysis and limbo status with no interim short term plan.
Not even anything ordered for these oldest stock :
Bakerloo now 50-53 years old, maybe a similar batch to Piccadilly line fleet in 2028-29, but nothing yet decided.
Scotrail HST fleet 43-48 years old, there is a tender but still unclear if interim fleet (possibly 222s ex East Midlands), or new bi-mode trains. This is Scottish Government not Westminster Government.
GWR night stock, over 40 years old, with locos originally built nearer 60 years ago, but no agreed plan for replacement.
Class 318s, about 40 years old, originally built for Ayrshire electrification. Scotland has tender for new EMUs and BEMUs
Class 150, now 38-40 years old. Used by multiple operators, only Wales seems to have a plan (when class 398 tram trains enter service, and stock is displaced)
Class 153 & 155, will put these together as some were reclassified, now around 36-37 years old, like 150s not a specific plan for most of remainder
Class 320 (and incorporating some shortened class 321), around 35-38 years old, covered by same tender as class 318
Class 156, another diesel class, 36-37 years old. Northern has a tender, Scotrail has BEMUs in tender with 318 replacements. But to date no idea has been signed off.
Class 158 & 159, now 33-36 years old with multiple operators, but looking like any replacements won't be in service before 2030. Dft seems to consider this as Northern phase 2 or part of GWR (and other operators) replacement.
Class 165 & 166, now 33-35 years old, a project Churchward exists, to replace them, but remains more an idea, as no tender has yet been issued. It does however exist on DfT procurement spreadsheet.
Class 465 & 466 the Networkers in South East London, now 32-35 years old, some already gone (indirectly replaced by 707s), there is a proposed tender on DfT procurement spreadsheet, but not issued yet.
For the record, here is link to DfT procurement spreadsheet
https://www.gov.uk/csv-preview/68ba8970d723ba6f74dbaa47/dft-future-commercial-contracts-dft-partners.csv
| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by eightonedee at 22:12, 29th November 2025 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
That rolling stock strategy is due out next summer, according to Lord Hendy. It sounds as though she actually knows about it, which is encouraging in a transport minister.
While having a national rolling stock strategy is one benefit of re-nationalisation, it's difficult to see how this can be produced without also having a strategy for electrification, and ensuring it is implemented.
| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by Bob_Blakey at 22:03, 29th November 2025 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
My judgment is still well & truly reserved; at the recent Transport Select Committee (TSC) Ms Alexander said that the c. £2bn annual passenger service subsidy absolutely had to be reduced. Shortly thereafter a national rail fare freeze, which she must have sanctioned, was announced. Doesn't exactly smell of joined up thinking does it?
At the same TSC she also stated that fare evasion was an issue that needed to be addressed. In which case a word with GWR wouldn't be a bad start; their repeated failure to check tickets/railcards has become a joke.
| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by TonyK at 15:01, 29th November 2025 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
That rolling stock strategy is due out next summer, according to Lord Hendy. It sounds as though she actually knows about it, which is encouraging in a transport minister.
| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by grahame at 07:16, 29th November 2025 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Well, at least she had some company!
The transport secretary has said she has sat on the floors of overcrowded trains as she vowed to improve the rail network.
And at least she had a train to sit on the floor of.
From her own constituency:
17:35 Swindon to Westbury due 18:18
19:44 Swindon to Westbury due 20:29
19:44 Swindon to Westbury due 20:29 will be cancelled.
This is due to a shortage of train crew.
19:44 Swindon to Westbury due 20:29
19:44 Swindon to Westbury due 20:29 will be cancelled.
This is due to a shortage of train crew.
Previous train - 15:14, next train 21:10, no instructions as to how to get home if - for example - you live in Melksham
| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by TaplowGreen at 07:03, 29th November 2025 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Well, at least she had some company!
| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by Chris from Nailsea at 05:49, 29th November 2025 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From the BBC:
'I've sat on train floors' - transport secretary

The transport secretary has said she has sat on the floors of overcrowded trains as she vowed to improve the rail network.
When asked about delays and overcrowding on the railways, Heidi Alexander told BBC Radio Wiltshire: "I've had this problem myself to be honest. I am on trains a lot and I've sat on the floor on a couple of occasions," the South Swindon MP added. "As Secretary of State, I've sat on the floor on a Great Western train from Paddington to Swindon."
She said managing driver and train crew availability was key to solving the problem alongside having a sufficient number of carriages on services. Great Western Railway has been contacted for comment.
Great Western Railway is among the four operators named in the government's plan to nationalise nearly all rail services in England. Launched earlier this year and expected to finish in 2027, the nationalisation process comes under the Rail Public Ownership Bill, which was passed by the government when Labour came to power last year. The government claims the move will "end years of fragmentation, driving up standards for passengers, and making journey easier and better value for money".
Shadow transport minister Jerome Mayhew previously said he feared that nationalisation would end up costing taxpayers more money in increased costs for leasing rolling stock. "The government is risking this successful operation for ideological reasons," he said.
Overcrowding on trains in the UK is not a new issue. In 2024, train passengers reported fainting on busy services while passengers quizzed rail bosses over the issue in 2023.
Ms Alexander said it was "really important" for passengers to have a "comfortable journey".
"We'll be doing more work on that as Great Western comes into public ownership," she added.
She said overcrowding is sometimes caused by trains on "short formations" - for example, where there is a "five-car train as opposed to a longer train turning up".
"The government is writing a new rolling stock strategy [an industry term for the train carriages]," she said.
Heidi Alexander was speaking to BBC Radio Wiltshire as part of the Bring Out The Boss series and also shared her views on a proposal to revoke planning consent for a tunnel to be built near Stonehenge and reacted the stabbing of the stabbing of an 18-year-old in north Swindon. Listen to the full interview here.

The transport secretary has said she has sat on the floors of overcrowded trains as she vowed to improve the rail network.
When asked about delays and overcrowding on the railways, Heidi Alexander told BBC Radio Wiltshire: "I've had this problem myself to be honest. I am on trains a lot and I've sat on the floor on a couple of occasions," the South Swindon MP added. "As Secretary of State, I've sat on the floor on a Great Western train from Paddington to Swindon."
She said managing driver and train crew availability was key to solving the problem alongside having a sufficient number of carriages on services. Great Western Railway has been contacted for comment.
Great Western Railway is among the four operators named in the government's plan to nationalise nearly all rail services in England. Launched earlier this year and expected to finish in 2027, the nationalisation process comes under the Rail Public Ownership Bill, which was passed by the government when Labour came to power last year. The government claims the move will "end years of fragmentation, driving up standards for passengers, and making journey easier and better value for money".
Shadow transport minister Jerome Mayhew previously said he feared that nationalisation would end up costing taxpayers more money in increased costs for leasing rolling stock. "The government is risking this successful operation for ideological reasons," he said.
Overcrowding on trains in the UK is not a new issue. In 2024, train passengers reported fainting on busy services while passengers quizzed rail bosses over the issue in 2023.
Ms Alexander said it was "really important" for passengers to have a "comfortable journey".
"We'll be doing more work on that as Great Western comes into public ownership," she added.
She said overcrowding is sometimes caused by trains on "short formations" - for example, where there is a "five-car train as opposed to a longer train turning up".
"The government is writing a new rolling stock strategy [an industry term for the train carriages]," she said.
Heidi Alexander was speaking to BBC Radio Wiltshire as part of the Bring Out The Boss series and also shared her views on a proposal to revoke planning consent for a tunnel to be built near Stonehenge and reacted the stabbing of the stabbing of an 18-year-old in north Swindon. Listen to the full interview here.
| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by Mark A at 11:08, 30th November 2024 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Guido Fawkes is not impressed by her record to date, describes it as a "train wreck transport career".
If the likes of that sort of source have gone straight on the attack, this implies that her work as transport secretary will be effective, but *looks around* someone needs to buy some trains.
That aside, for Bristol, the Portishead quick win, but with a Leven-style 2 platform terminus pls and thq.
Oh and direct trains between Bristol and Waterloo and sort out London Bridge so travel from various stations in her previous constituency doesn't involve using it as the interchange for which it is most definitely not suited.
Mark
| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by TaplowGreen at 09:24, 30th November 2024 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Guido Fawkes is not impressed by her record to date, describes it as a "train wreck transport career".
You could say the same about any Tory Secretary of State in recent years, except perhaps Anne-Marie Trevelyan who wasn't in post long enough to anything much good or bad.
I'd rather hear thoughts about how she's going to be better, rather than more "yeah but the Tories"
Guido is hardly the most objective or unbiased of sources, are any of the points he makes inaccurate?
| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by ellendune at 08:40, 30th November 2024 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Guido Fawkes is not impressed by her record to date, describes it as a "train wreck transport career".
You could say the same about any Tory Secretary of State in recent years, except perhaps Anne-Marie Trevelyan who wasn't in post long enough to anything much good or bad.
| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by grahame at 05:49, 30th November 2024 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Guido Fawkes is not impressed by her record to date, describes it as a "train wreck transport career".
| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by TonyK at 19:43, 29th November 2024 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Welcome, Minister. If I promise not to start searching for skellingtons in your closet, will you sign off the Portishead reopening and send the cheque?
| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by Electric train at 18:18, 29th November 2024 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
A Swindon MP, former deputy mayor for transport in London, and a (newcomer) cyclist. That's a promising CV.
Now if only she would reopen Swindon Works

| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by grahame at 16:58, 29th November 2024 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Also represents the Labour constituency closest to Melksham! 

Indeed - I would need to check new boundaries, but I think Swindon Station is half in her constituency?
| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by froome at 16:47, 29th November 2024 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Also represents the Labour constituency closest to Melksham!

| Re: Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by Richard Fairhurst at 13:03, 29th November 2024 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
A Swindon MP, former deputy mayor for transport in London, and a (newcomer) cyclist. That's a promising CV.
| Heidi Alexander, Transport Secretary Posted by Chris from Nailsea at 12:33, 29th November 2024 | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From Downing Street:
Heidi Alexander MP @Heidi_Labour has been appointed Secretary of State for Transport @TransportGovUK.














